Mentoring can help strengthen understanding of subjects, increase confidence, and develop important learning skills. Tutoring provides students with individualized attention that they don't receive in a crowded classroom. This helps children struggling to keep up, as well as those who don't have enough challenges. As I wrote in the post, some tutors are really good and useful.
If you're struggling in a class, a tutor can really make a positive difference. But when you have a tutor for each class, do you need it or not? (A lot of students do. I have worked with hundreds of students and have seen it over and over again. I have studied psychology, motivation and management, and having unnecessary (or bad) tutors violates what I would consider to be some of the most important lessons from these fields.
Where did you find the data to give truth to your argument that hiring tutors leads to real progress, and not just to better grades in homework? Having a good tutor to help your child master the basics of difficult subjects will make it easier for him to follow classes. In the long term, your child will be able to understand more advanced material because his basics are solid. And as a bonus, your grades will improve over time. Mentoring can be equated with the type of Socratic questioning, therefore effective tutoring must be taught and learned.
It is important that the tutor you use receives regular counseling from a third party, such as a more experienced tutor, to help develop their self-awareness as a guardian. These options are offered both by tutoring companies that hire many tutors and by individuals, such as university students and professors. A study has shown that private tutoring can help students if the tutor understands the family situation and life circumstances of their students. As part of being in the tutoring industry, I have spoken to a large number of students who have also received tutoring from other companies.
Studies have shown that tutors who coordinate private tutoring sessions with the curriculum taught in school help students more than teach unrelated subjects. When a guardian works as a “homework machine” for your child, it would probably be better if your child didn't have a guardian at all. A good tutor will ask the student to find the definition in the textbook, read it a few times, and then the tutor will check the comprehension by asking the student to give the definition in their own words or to use the new concept in a mathematics problem. You must carefully select a private tutor or institution that provides private tutoring services or else you risk wasting your time and money.
Another important factor for successful private tutoring is a positive relationship between tutor and student. Proper math tutoring should demonstrate during each tutoring session how learning mathematics occurs in general. While tutoring is more likely to benefit the student than not, research on tutoring is contradictory because there are so many factors at play. While I believe in consistent and ongoing mentoring to achieve the desired results, I recommend that parents seek flexible pay-as-you-go tutoring arrangements so that families only buy and receive the time that the student really needs.
When the student did not know how to solve an assignment math problem, the tutor would show him all the steps necessary to solve the problem and then the student would solve a similar problem by imitating the steps he had learned from the tutor.